Turkish diplomacy remains silent – ANALYSIS
It is important to pay attention to the chronology of developments and statements to imagine the essence of the issue. APA reported quoting turkgundem.net website on February 12 that one of the participants of the Armenian-Turkish talks as saying that Ankara retracted its previous term of withdrawal of Armenian troops from the occupied lands of Azerbaijan for establishing the official relations and opening the borders with Armenia. The radio claimed that only term of the Turkish government now is the establishing of joint commission of historians for investigation of 1915 events.
There are reasons of such kind of reports. If we pay attention to the recent developments, we cans see that Turkey played an active role in geopolitical arena of South Caucasus. The war between Georgia and Russia exposed the policy pursued by the US and Russia in South Caucasus. Official Washington’s approach towards all issues from its point of view, Moscow’s strict resistance to it and its inadequate impact on Georgia questioned hopes for two super powers. Turkey took an initiative and attempted to own regulative lever in South Caucasus and it was very understandable. Turkey’s Caucasus Stability Pact, visits to Moscow, Yerevan and Baku showed that Turkish officials had taken a serious interest in the issue.
Turkey’s attempts on taking an initiative in South Caucasus cannot be separately considered from interior affairs and integration into European Union.
It is obvious that the European Union laid commitments on Turkey and one of these commitments is the normalization of the relations with Armenia. No doubt the campaigns “We all are Hrant Dinks!â€, “Let’s apologize to Armenians!†are linked to this issue. This explains Turkey’s milder attitude towards Armenia recently. At first sight, Abdullah Gul’s visit to Armenia, Sarkisian’s visit to Turkey, moreover a number of meetings on the highest level created impression that Turkey is active in the South Caucasus, but the real essence became obvious later.
Long before, leak of information from Turkish official circles to the local media raised doubts that official Ankara had changed its position. Foreign Minister Ali Babacan’s interviews and various statements strengthened these doubts. It is not accidental that in Germany, and later during his recent visit to Azerbaijan Ali Babacan preferred to avoid media’s questions about changes in Turkey’s position in terms of Nagorno Karabakh problem. Foreign Minister’s repeated statements that Turkey and Azerbaijan separately had talks with Armenia showed that the unique position of Azerbaijan and Turkey with respect to Armenia had changed.
On February 12, visiting the line of contact in Goranboy region, Turkish Ambassador to Azerbaijan Hulusi Kilich expressed Ankara’s traditional position on Nagorno Karabakh problem. An hour later Armenian service of Radio Liberty spread the known information and media again asked Hulusi Kilich to comment on the issue. At that time the ambassador told APA that he was returning from Ganja to Baku, he noted that he would concern himself with the issue and make a statement after returning. Besides, Hulusi Kilich said he did not believe it. But despite media’s appeals Turkish ambassador did not say a word. He only said: “I am not the ambassador, who speaks in the streetâ€. Turkish Foreign Ministry was also closed for Azerbaijani media, nobody wanted to answer such a short and concrete question. On February 13, Foreign Ministry spokesman Burak Ozugergin said in his statement to Anadolu agency: “The current process between Turkey and Armenia aim at normalizing the relations between the two countries. On the other hand, Azerbaijan and Armenia are also having a dialogue. The processes are parallel. It is expected that an improvement on one side will have a positive influence on the other side. We do not comment on the information based on some sensations.†As seen, there is nothing more than the repeat of Ali Babacan’s traditional expressions.
Turkish government said the issue on the level of Deputy Prime Minister Geybulla Geybullayev and State Minister Cemil Chichek was not true. The said it was a lie and provocation and that Turkey did not retract from its condition in terms of Nagorno Karabakh. On February 17, Turkish parliamentarian, head of Turkey-Azerbaijan friendship group Mustafa Kabakchi told APA on behalf of Turkish state that the report was groundless.
It is interesting that the deputy prime ministers of Turkey have made statements while the Foreign Ministry is keeping silence.
It causes several assumptions. First, part of the government officials have no idea about these talks; second, some of the Turkish authorities don’t share this position; third, announcements of the state ministers and parliamentarians, who have not been involved in the Turkish-Armenian talks, have no special responsibility. However, Ali Babacan, who has directly participated in the talks, told journalists clearly that he prefers to keep silence. For example, early this month Babacan told journalists in Munich that they targeted to normalize relations in the region. “We begin talks with Armenia to normalize relations in the region. If we achieve the normal relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan, Armenia and Turkey, it will change many things in the region. If we achieve these changes, it will be advantageous for all parties. Now we should talk behind the closed doors and let to make public only what we want to announce.â€
Today Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan expressed his opinion on this issue. “There is no any change in our position on Karabakh, which could differ from the official position of Azerbaijan. We determined our positions together and are continuing it together up to date. It is out of question. We are sharing the official position of Azerbaijan and are staying behind this position up to date. Azerbaijan’s fairness in the Karabakh issue is clear and it was described in the UN resolution tooâ€.
However Erdogan left many questions without answers. How important is the Nagorno Karabakh issue in the Turkish-Armenian relations? How long will Turkey continue these talks if Armenia doesn’t withdraw from Nagorno Karabakh? May Turkey open the borders with Armenia before finding the solution to the Nagorno Karabakh problem? Will the part of behind-closed-doors talks about Azerbaijan be announced, or they will announce only what they want?
We are looking for the foreign minister of Turkey and ambassador of Azerbaijan to find answers to these questions.
…..Azerbaijan is in waiting!
Political
Ilham Aliyev achieved to return Gazakh's 4 villages to Azerbaijan without single bullet or bloodshed -ANALYSIS
Parisian stance: France is experiencing diplomatic stress in its relations with Azerbaijan and taking chaotic steps -ANALYTICS
France-Russia confrontation is escalating openly: Paris turns into Moscow's main geopolitical rival-ANALYSIS
Endless games of ICRC: Time comes for organization to leave Azerbaijan -ANALYTICS
NEWS FEED
UN Secretary-General calls on Azerbaijan and Armenia to tackle all outstanding bilateral issues
UN SecGen calls on Azerbaijan and Armenia to resolve all issues to normalize relations
US welcomes agreement on return of Azerbaijan's four villages
Ecuador president declares state of emergency over energy crisis
Venezuela opposition backs Gonzalez as presidential candidate
3 wounded in Iraq explosions, official says. Israel denies involvement
US Congress close to passing long-awaited Ukraine aid
UNGA president highlights success of first Sustainability Week
Iraqi Shiite militia claims drone attack on Israel
At least 15 dead in boat sinking in Central African Republic
DPRK test-fires new anti-aircraft missile
Three injured after chemical plant fire in U.S. Houston
Russian government increases customs duties on beer from unfriendly countries
Chairmanship of COP29 will bring Azerbaijan closer to its global goals - Minister
EU, Finnish leaders call for de-escalation amid Iran-Israel tensions
Azerbaijani pavilion launched at 60th Venice Biennale-PHOTO
EU welcomes agreement on return of 4 villages of Azerbaijan's Gazakh
Western Azerbaijan Community: G7 damages normalization of Azerbaijani-Armenian relations
Netherlands allocates over $210 million for ammunition for Ukraine
NATO Chief: "There are systems including Patriot systems available to be provided to Ukraine"
Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan hold consular consultations-PHOTO
House votes to advance foreign aid bills, despite GOP defections
NATO allies pledge additional air defence systems for Kyiv, Stoltenberg says
Azerbaijani FM received Algerian ambassador on occasion of end of his diplomatic tenure
Italy demonstrated a fair position during a critical moment, Azerbaijani FM says
Italian Ambassador completes his diplomatic tenure in Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan, Japan mull cooperation possibilities in field of tourism
Azerbaijan State Oil Fund’s assets exceed USD 57 bln.
Ilham Aliyev achieved to return Gazakh's 4 villages to Azerbaijan without single bullet or bloodshed -ANALYSIS
Armenia agreed to return 4 villages of Azerbaijan that were under occupation - Azerbaijani MFA
Azerbaijan exchanges experience with Türkiye on occupational safety and hygiene
Azerbaijan and Armenia agreed to base their delimitation process on Alma-Ata Declaration
Baku, Yerevan to deploy their border services simultaneously and in parallel on agreed parts of border line
Azerbaijan and Armenia agree on returning of Gazakh's 4 villages
Azerbaijan-Armenia delimitation commission holds next meeting, reaches an agreement on number of issues
Police arrest man in Paris Iran consulate incident, source says -UPDATED
Azerbaijani President to visit Germany, hold talks with Chancellor
Russian, Azerbaijani Presidents to meet in Moscow
Armenia benefits the most from EurAsEC - Russian FM
G7 Foreign Ministers call Azerbaijan and Armenia to be committed to peace process
Baku French Lyceum ceases its activity-UPDATED
Azerbaijan's Prosecutor General made remark at IPA meeting in China
Russia won’t allow NATO to move closer in Ukraine — Lavrov
Russia calls on all sides to exercise restraint in Middle East - Kremlin
"Azerbaijan Airlines" CJSC became a member of the ACI Europe
Azerbaijani FM, Palestinian PM discuss situation in Gaza
Azercell announces Crisis Management Group Project
Hearings at International Court of Justice based on Azerbaijan's preliminary objections concludes
No plans for pauses in fighting if talks on Ukraine begin, Lavrov says
Russia knows French military instructors working in Ukraine — Lavrov