Analysis: Is Turkey turning east?
Caucasus Update No. 53
Caucasian Review of International Affairs (CRIA)
www.cria-online.org
For some time, there have been fears that Turkey has begun moving away from its traditional Euro-Atlantic orientation, towards the Middle East and the Muslim world. Turkey’s condemnation of Israel’s attack on Gaza in January was followed by Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s walk-out during a debate with Israeli President Shimon Peres at the World Economic Forum.
In early October, Turkey vetoed Israel’s participation in a joint air-force exercise, again citing its conduct in Gaza. In the same week Turkish TV aired a show portraying Israeli soldiers as child- killers, provoking fury in Tel Aviv.
On a recent visit to Iran, the Turkish premier signed a gas deal and several economic cooperation agreements (Press TV, October 28). Before the visit, Mr Erdogan defended Iran’s right to nuclear energy and accused those countries which oppose Tehran’s atomic program of hypocrisy (Guardian, October 26). Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was understandably delighted, and pundits in the West were understandably shaken.
The New York Times argued that lack of progress on EU membership was driving Turkey away (NY Times, October 27). The Christian Science Monitor called it ‘worrisome’ (Christian Science Monitor, October 29). Overall, the assumption seems to be that Turkey’s growing clout, and disillusionment with its EU membership talks, is leading it towards a closer relationship with autocratic Middle Eastern states like Iran and Syria.
So are Europe and America ‘losing’ Turkey? Probably not. The evidence in support of this theory is disjointed and selective, and ignores other key facts. On Israel, for instance, this argument assumes that Turkey’s fury over Gaza is in some way manufactured, that it is designed entirely to win support on the ‘Arab street’ (and indeed the Persian street).
Although Turkey’s leaders are not blind to the credit that this will earn them in the Muslim world (also, within Turkey itself), there is little doubt that their anger is genuine. Turkey has been attempting to encourage progress on the Arab-Israeli peace process for years, and saw its fragile gains destroyed during Operation Cast Lead. Rightly or wrongly, Ankara sees Israel as mainly responsible. As for the TV program, it would be absurd to assume that the Turkish government was responsible for the content and the timing.
It is also odd to link Turkish anger at Israel with turning away from the EU. For all its links with Brussels and Washington, the Jewish state is not an integral part of ‘the West’, geographically or politically. Ankara is quite capable of opposing Israel’s actions without abandoning its EU membership application. And although the reputation of that process is heavily tarnished, and there is significant frustration amongst ordinary Turks over European hostility to Turkish membership, EU integration remains a priority of the AKP Government.
Senior Turkish officials have made this plain in recent days. They also poured cold water on the whole idea that Turkey is turning East – “Is it so easy to change direction?†asked President Abdullah Gul rhetorically (Today’s Zaman, October 30).
This statement hints at the heart of the matter. Complex states do not have a single geopolitical ‘direction’. President Gul visited Serbia on October 26th, but this hardly means that Ankara is seeking to re-establish Ottoman influence in the Balkans, as some seem to believe it is doing in the Middle East. To take another parallel, no-one would seriously believe that increased US diplomacy towards China would be a sign of abandoning NATO and Europe.
Ankara’s foreign policy, now more than ever, is famously focused on ‘zero problems with neighbours’ (RFE/RL, October 30). Given Turkey’s unique position at the confluence of so many different regions, this policy is bound to involve dealing with states whom the West distrusts – Iran, Russia, and Syria, for instance.
Expecting Turkey to suspend cooperation with Tehran is an easy judgement to make in Washington or Brussels, but not so in Ankara. An otherwise hostile Wall Street Journal acknowledged this on October 30, recognising that “nations do not have the luxury of picking their neighbours†(Wall Street Journal, October 30). Turkey needs Iran to cooperate: on energy, trade, and on containing Kurdish militants.
In any case, Turkey has absolutely no interest in a nuclear Iran. What most commentaries fearing a Turkish-Iranian alliance ignore is that, just a few weeks ago, Ankara ordered advanced Patriot missile batteries from the US (Eurasia Daily Monitor, September 16). It was keen to insist that this was not due to any threat, but the move is obviously in response to Iran’s strategic missile programme. Mr Erdogan’s praise of President Ahmadinejad was, given this context, simple diplomacy, made before a visit in which he hoped to secure extensive trade and energy deals. It would have been surprising, and contrary to Turkey’s foreign policy, to have prepared for his visit by thundering against the country’s nuclear program.
The ‘losing Turkey’ argument – which assumes that, given the AK Party’s Islamist past, Turkey is also becoming more Islamic in nature - also ignores moves such as the thaw with Christian Armenia. This was also undertaken in the framework of the same “zero problems†concept.
Assuming that Turkey is somehow moving away from the West, towards the Middle East, or towards some kind of pact with Iran, is a narrow view. It ignores historic rivalry between them, fails to recognise Turkish fears of an Iranian nuclear weapon (whatever Mr Erdogan might say in public), and conflates Israel with the EU or NATO. Most importantly, it underestimates Ankara’s foreign policy. Turkey is smart enough to be able to look East and West at the same time.
Political
Ilham Aliyev achieved to return Gazakh's 4 villages to Azerbaijan without single bullet or bloodshed -ANALYSIS
Parisian stance: France is experiencing diplomatic stress in its relations with Azerbaijan and taking chaotic steps -ANALYTICS
France-Russia confrontation is escalating openly: Paris turns into Moscow's main geopolitical rival-ANALYSIS
Endless games of ICRC: Time comes for organization to leave Azerbaijan -ANALYTICS
NEWS FEED
At least 15 dead in boat sinking in Central African Republic
DPRK test-fires new anti-aircraft missile
Three injured after chemical plant fire in U.S. Houston
Russian government increases customs duties on beer from unfriendly countries
Chairmanship of COP29 will bring Azerbaijan closer to its global goals - Minister
EU, Finnish leaders call for de-escalation amid Iran-Israel tensions
Azerbaijani pavilion launched at 60th Venice Biennale-PHOTO
EU welcomes agreement on return of 4 villages of Azerbaijan's Gazakh
Western Azerbaijan Community: G7 damages normalization of Azerbaijani-Armenian relations
Netherlands allocates over $210 million for ammunition for Ukraine
NATO Chief: "There are systems including Patriot systems available to be provided to Ukraine"
Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan hold consular consultations-PHOTO
House votes to advance foreign aid bills, despite GOP defections
NATO allies pledge additional air defence systems for Kyiv, Stoltenberg says
Azerbaijani FM received Algerian ambassador on occasion of end of his diplomatic tenure
Italy demonstrated a fair position during a critical moment, Azerbaijani FM says
Italian Ambassador completes his diplomatic tenure in Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan, Japan mull cooperation possibilities in field of tourism
Azerbaijan State Oil Fund’s assets exceed USD 57 bln.
Ilham Aliyev achieved to return Gazakh's 4 villages to Azerbaijan without single bullet or bloodshed -ANALYSIS
Armenia agreed to return 4 villages of Azerbaijan that were under occupation - Azerbaijani MFA
Azerbaijan exchanges experience with Türkiye on occupational safety and hygiene
Azerbaijan and Armenia agreed to base their delimitation process on Alma-Ata Declaration
Baku, Yerevan to deploy their border services simultaneously and in parallel on agreed parts of border line
Azerbaijan and Armenia agree on returning of Gazakh's 4 villages
Azerbaijan-Armenia delimitation commission holds next meeting, reaches an agreement on number of issues
Police arrest man in Paris Iran consulate incident, source says -UPDATED
Azerbaijani President to visit Germany, hold talks with Chancellor
Russian, Azerbaijani Presidents to meet in Moscow
Armenia benefits the most from EurAsEC - Russian FM
G7 Foreign Ministers call Azerbaijan and Armenia to be committed to peace process
Baku French Lyceum ceases its activity-UPDATED
Azerbaijan's Prosecutor General made remark at IPA meeting in China
Russia won’t allow NATO to move closer in Ukraine — Lavrov
Russia calls on all sides to exercise restraint in Middle East - Kremlin
"Azerbaijan Airlines" CJSC became a member of the ACI Europe
Azerbaijani FM, Palestinian PM discuss situation in Gaza
Azercell announces Crisis Management Group Project
Hearings at International Court of Justice based on Azerbaijan's preliminary objections concludes
No plans for pauses in fighting if talks on Ukraine begin, Lavrov says
Russia knows French military instructors working in Ukraine — Lavrov
NATO concerned about adoption of foreign agents law in Georgian parliament
Turkish Foreign Ministry called on Israel and Iran
Leader of the region: Baku Airport again awarded Skytrax
Nigerian military kills 192 suspected terrorists in one week
Russian FM outlined some aspects of the Istanbul agreement with Ukraine
Azerbaijan to create artificial land plots in Caspian Sea for construction
Apple deletes WhatsApp, Threads from China app store on orders from Beijing
Rosatom ready to implement renewable energy projects in Türkiye- Akkuyu Nuclear
Azerbaijan will grant fathers right to receive a labor pension under favorable conditions for children